Threat Modeling: Who’s Watching and Why It Matters
Threat modeling sounds like something for intelligence agencies. In reality, it’s a practical framework anyone can use to understand their privacy risks and choose appropriate protections.
The four questions
Every threat model starts with four questions:
1. What am I protecting?
Your list might include:
- Home address and daily routine
- Financial information
- Health information
- Political activities or beliefs
- Relationship status and partner information
- Location history and travel patterns
- Professional intellectual property
- Communications with specific people
2. Who am I protecting it from?
Different adversaries have different capabilities:
- Advertisers: Sophisticated tracking, limited by law
- Data brokers: Aggregate public and purchased data
- Stalkers/abusers: May have physical access to your devices
- Employers: Can monitor company-owned devices
- Local police: Subpoena power, ALPR, camera access
- Federal agencies: Extensive technical capabilities, legal authority
- Nation states: Nearly unlimited capabilities
3. What happens if I fail?
The consequences determine how much effort is appropriate:
- Targeted advertising (annoying, not dangerous)
- Identity theft (financial damage, time to resolve)
- Employment consequences (career impact)
- Physical safety threats (domestic violence, political persecution)
- Legal consequences (depending on jurisdiction and activities)
4. How likely is the threat?
Not every threat requires maximum protection. A journalist covering organized crime faces different risks than someone who just wants fewer targeted ads.
Practical levels
Level 1: Basic hygiene (everyone should do this):
- Use a password manager
- Enable two-factor authentication
- Use Shield or a privacy browser extension
- Review app permissions
Level 2: Active privacy (most people reading this):
- Use Signal for sensitive conversations
- Private search engine (DuckDuckGo, Brave Search)
- VPN on public WiFi
- Check Sentinel for camera awareness on your routes
- Opt out of data brokers
Level 3: Operational security (journalists, activists, at-risk individuals):
- Compartmentalize devices and identities
- Tor for sensitive research
- Physical counter-surveillance awareness
- Encrypted storage for sensitive documents
- Secure communication protocols with sources
Level 4: High security (targeted individuals, whistleblowers):
- Dedicated secure devices
- Full operational security protocols
- Tails OS for sensitive work
- Counter-surveillance sweeps
- Legal consultation on surveillance risks
Most people need Level 1-2. Know which level you need and don’t under-invest or over-invest.